Table of Contents

Looking for the right intelligence solution?

Explore Molfar Intelligence services to find the expertise that fits your needs.

Explore our services
Explore our services
Black Plus Icon

Author

Former British Army officer, trained in surveillance and target acquisition, and Bain and Company engagement manager, with more than a decade of experience working in consulting, private equity and venture capital across Western Europe.

Employee fraud can first appear as an unusual expense, a disputed payroll change or an unexpected connection to a supplier. Each raises a different question. The business needs to establish what happened before deciding how to respond.

A useful investigation connects public information with internal records. Who had an interest in the transaction? Who authorised it? What did the business receive, and where did the payment go?

Key takeaways

  • Separate suspicious transactions from weaknesses that make fraud possible.
  • Public records can reveal corporate relationships. Internal evidence establishes how those relationships affected business decisions.
  • Check the relationship, approval, performance and payment separately.
  • Preserve relevant records, test competing explanations and keep evidence collection lawful and proportionate.

What is employee fraud?

Employee fraud involves deliberate dishonesty connected with a person’s work, intended to obtain a gain, cause a loss or expose someone to the risk of loss. The intended beneficiary may be the employee, another party or the organisation itself.

Related conduct can involve temporary staff, contractors or outsiders working with an employee. Its legal classification depends on the facts and applicable jurisdiction. An error or disciplinary breach should not automatically be labelled a criminal offence.

Examples of employee fraud

False expenses and company-card claims

An employee knowingly alters a receipt, claims the same cost twice or presents a personal purchase as a business expense. Compare the claim with the original transaction, business purpose and previous reimbursements.

Payroll manipulation

Someone creates a fictitious worker, deliberately inflates hours or makes an unauthorised pay change. Reconcile payroll with employment records, approved rates, attendance evidence and the history of changes.

Supplier collusion and false invoices

An employee steers work towards a connected supplier, approves invoices for work not completed or receives an undisclosed benefit. The procurement fraud guide explains how to examine the award, delivery and payment stages.

Diversion of money or assets

Examples include redirecting a customer refund or concealing the unauthorised disposal of stock. Establish the destination, authority and circumstances of the transaction. An external impersonation attack is one alternative explanation for changed payment instructions.

Dishonest financial reporting

An employee falsifies sales, liabilities or performance records to obtain a bonus or mislead another party. Examine the transactions behind the reported figures. In some schemes, the organisation is an intended beneficiary rather than the victim.

Misuse of confidential information

An employee may disclose information as part of a dishonest arrangement with a competitor or supplier. Establish what was disclosed, who received it and how the disclosure relates to the alleged scheme. A data incident requires its own factual and legal assessment.

Which warning signs justify a closer review?

Start with discrepancies that can be checked against an original record:

  • Repeated exceptions: the same person regularly bypasses approval or documentation requirements.
  • Unexpected payment changes: beneficiary details change without independent verification.
  • Conflicting records: expenses, timesheets, delivery records or accounts do not reconcile.
  • Undeclared connections: available information suggests a relevant employee relationship with a supplier or customer.

For each discrepancy, identify the transaction, relevant period and expected approval process. This turns a general suspicion into a question the investigator can test.

Control weaknesses are different. One person being able to create a supplier, approve its invoice and release payment increases exposure, but does not show that the person has abused those permissions. Record the weakness separately from any findings about conduct.

What OSINT can establish about employee–supplier links

Companies House records can identify declared directorships, persons with significant control and changes in corporate roles. Archived websites, published procurement records and relevant professional profiles may help reconstruct a supplier’s activity during the period under review.

Use historical records where the allegation concerns an earlier transaction. A current appointment list may not show who held a role when the supplier was selected.

A directorship is also different from ownership or control. The ultimate beneficial owner guide explains how those roles can overlap and where they differ.

Public records help identify relationships to examine. Contract approvals, employee declarations, delivery evidence and private payment records generally require other sources obtained through authorised channels.

A four-stage evidence check: an employee–supplier example

Consider a fictional consultancy engagement. A register search suggests that the employee managing the contract is also a director of the supplier. The supplier has invoiced for completed work.

The following structure organises the investigation. It is not a legal test requiring every fraud case to follow the same pattern.

  1. Relationship. Corroborate the employee’s identity and the appointment dates. Compare the corporate role with declarations of interest and any other recorded disclosures.
  2. Approval. Establish who selected the supplier, approved the engagement and signed off the invoice. An entry under an employee’s account needs to be assessed alongside delegated authority, shared access and other relevant records before attributing the action personally.
  3. Performance. Identify the contracted output and evidence that the business received it. For consultancy work, this might include a report, project records and independent acceptance against the agreed scope.
  4. Payment. Reconcile the approved invoice with the actual payment and beneficiary details. A payment to the supplier identifies an immediate recipient. Any alleged onward transfer or kickback requires separate evidence.

Outcome A: the evidence explains the relationship

Suppose the interest was declared before supplier selection. The employee took no part in the award or acceptance decision. An independent manager approved the engagement and verified the agreed work.

These findings address the original concern about an undisclosed, conflicted decision. The corporate connection no longer carries the same significance. Document how the interest was managed rather than continuing to treat the directorship itself as evidence of wrongdoing.

Outcome B: the evidence identifies specific unresolved conduct

In a second hypothetical outcome, the reviewed declarations contain no record of the interest. Other records corroborate the employee’s personal involvement in approval. The investigation has not located the contracted output or independent acceptance evidence.

The next checks are specific: seek any disclosure made through another channel, obtain the employee’s explanation and establish what work was supplied. These findings justify further investigation into disclosure, approval and performance. They do not yet establish a fictitious service or kickback.

The value of the exercise is the change in the investigation’s direction. New evidence either explains the original concern or narrows it to conduct that can be examined further.

How to investigate suspected employee fraud

Define the allegation and appoint an appropriate investigator

Specify the transaction, conduct and period under review. Avoid a general search for anything adverse about the employee. Check the investigator’s expertise, independence and potential conflicts of interest.

Preserve relevant evidence

Retain original documents, approval histories and relevant system records through authorised channels. Record their source, collection date and handling. Protect relevant material from routine deletion where appropriate.

Test competing explanations

Compare the allegation with original documents. Examine authorised exceptions, submission errors, delegated decisions or compromised accounts where relevant. Give the employee an appropriate opportunity to respond as part of the applicable process.

Keep collection lawful and proportionate

Define the purpose, lawful basis, access permissions and necessary scope before collecting personal information. Limit access to those who need it. Allegations involving criminal conduct can raise additional data-protection requirements.

Separate immediate safeguards from final findings

Assess whether temporary access changes, additional payment approval or another measure is needed to protect the business and evidence. Suspension should not be automatic or treated as punishment. Document the reasons for any measure and review it.

The final report should distinguish confirmed facts, disputed evidence and unanswered questions. Refer disciplinary, reporting and legal decisions to the responsible teams.

How employers can reduce employee fraud risk

Separate supplier creation, invoice approval and payment release. Where a small team cannot fully divide those tasks, arrange an independent review of new payees and exceptions. The vendor verification guide explains checks on supplier records, payment details and changes during the relationship.

Require relevant interests to be declared and reviewed. Maintain confidential reporting routes that do not depend solely on the employee’s line manager. Review access when responsibilities change and ensure senior staff follow the same approval rules.

Risk-based employment background screening can verify relevant claims before appointment. Checks should follow the role and applicable rules. A clear screening result does not replace controls throughout employment.

Where Molfar Intelligence can help

Molfar Intelligence’s financial investigations examine suspicious transactions, company relationships and the evidence behind payment explanations. This work can help an internal team establish a relevant connection or reconstruct events across multiple sources.

To scope a review, identify the allegation, relevant dates, available records and the decision the business needs to make. The investigation does not replace legal advice, forensic examination where required or the employer’s responsibility for a fair process.

FAQ

How should a UK employer investigate suspected employee fraud without assuming guilt?

Define a specific allegation and appoint an appropriate investigator. Preserve relevant records, examine supporting and contradictory evidence, and follow the applicable employment process. Keep immediate safeguards separate from disciplinary findings.

What should an employer check after finding an employee in a supplier’s Companies House records?

Confirm identity and appointment dates, then review disclosures, procurement responsibilities and approval records. Check whether the employee influenced the transaction and whether any conflict was managed. The relevant question is how the relationship affected the business decision.

Can an employer read a worker’s emails when investigating suspected fraud?

The employer must consider the legal basis, necessity, proportionality and applicable monitoring arrangements. First establish whether less intrusive records can answer the question. Refer exceptional or covert collection to qualified advisers rather than treating it as routine.

Does the UK failure to prevent fraud offence apply whenever an employee steals from the employer?

No. The offence concerns specified fraud intended to benefit an organisation or certain clients and applies to organisations within its scope. Employee theft against the employer does not automatically trigger it. The intended beneficiary, victim and other statutory conditions require separate assessment.

‍

Turn Intelligence Into Action
Order a service
Order a service
Black Plus Icon

Recent posts

View all
View all
White Plus Icon
View all
View all
White Plus Icon

Related posts

View all
View all
White Plus Icon
View all
View all
White Plus Icon
Gain the Clarity You Need to Move with Confidence

Let’s connect to explore how tailored intelligence can strengthen your decisions, reveal opportunities, and minimise uncertainty.

Lorem Lorem

Lorem Ipsum Lorem Ipsum Lorem Ipsum Lorem Ipsum Lorem Ipsum

Contact
Contact
White Plus Icon
Lorem Ipsum Lorem Ipsum Lorem Ipsum Lorem Ipsum Lorem Ipsum Lorem Ipsum Lorem Ipsum Lorem Ipsum Lorem Ipsum Lorem Ipsum Lorem Ipsum Lorem Ipsum Lorem Ipsum Lorem Ipsum
Contact
Contact
White Plus Icon